Kirkland Cat Food vs Blue Buffalo Cat Food: You’ll Know in 1 Minute



Kirkland Cat Food vs Blue Buffalo is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from qualifying purchases.

When it comes to treating our feline friends to the most nutritious food in the bowl, the Kirkland cat food vs Blue Buffalo debate pops up like a curious cat behind a curtain. 

So, you might be asking: which cat food brand truly takes the top spot in satisfying those furry taste buds? Yet, variations in ingredients, value, and feline satisfaction set them apart. Ready to unravel this comparison? 

Stick around, and we’ll break down every piece of information, ensuring that by the end of this read, you’ll know exactly which brand your cat would purr-scribe to!

Kirkland Cat Food Overview

Kirkland Cat Food Overview

Kirkland Signature is the private label of Costco., a brand that’s become synonymous with bulk-buying and value. Introduced in the 1990s, Kirkland aimed to produce premium products at a fraction of the cost. Their cat food line quickly became a favorite, blending quality with affordability.

Established in the belief that quality shouldn’t break the bank, Kirkland has been committed to providing nutritious options for cats. Their cat food offerings are crafted to match or even surpass premium brands in terms of nutritional value, minus the hefty price tag.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Overview

Blue Buffalo Cat Food Overview

Born out of love for a family dog named Blue, Blue Buffalo entered the market in the early 2000s. After facing health issues with their beloved pet, the Bishop family felt a strong need for genuine, high-quality pet foods. And thus, they embarked on creating a brand that emphasized natural ingredients.

Love them like family; feed them like family.” This has been the motto of Blue Buffalo. The brand is committed to transparency and prioritizes natural ingredients, steering clear of artificial additives. Their innovative inclusion of “LifeSource Bits,” a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals showcases their dedication to pet health.

Kirkland Cat Food vs Blue Buffalo Cat Food: Comparison in Detail

Kirkland Cat Food

Kirkland Cat Food

Tailored nutrition for the little ones, ensuring they get a balanced start.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Cat Food

Recognizing that different-sized cats have varying nutritional requirements.

Ingredient Quality

KeyKirkland Cat Food Blue Buffalo Cat Food
Primary Proteins Often feature chicken, turkey, or fish as the first ingredient, indicating a high protein content.Deboned chicken, fish, or lamb commonly lead the ingredient list.
Fats Utilize sources like chicken fat and salmon oil for omega fatty acids.Incorporates flaxseed and fish oils for a balanced omega profile.
FillersMinimal use of fillers and an emphasis on natural ingredients.Prides itself on not using corn, wheat, soy, or chicken (or poultry) by-product meals.

Nutritional Profile

Kirkland comes with a typically high protein content, promoting lean muscle development. Fortified with essential vitamins and minerals. Its special feature is that it offers grain-free options suitable for cats with grain sensitivities.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo comes in equally high, aligning with the carnivorous needs of cats. Features “LifeSource Bits” – a unique blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals. Its special feature is that it provides specialized diet options, like weight management and sensitive stomach formulas.

Variety & Specialization

KeyKirkland Cat FoodBlue Buffalo
Range of Flavors and RecipesThey cater to various taste buds, from ocean fish meals to chicken and turkey delights.
Grain-free options, ensuring cats with sensitive stomachs aren’t left out.
A grain-free, high-protein line mimicking the diet of wild cats.
Simplified, limited-ingredient diets for cats with food sensitivities.
Grain-free options for those looking to avoid gluten and grains entirely.
Special Diet OptionsSenior and weight management options: For older cats or those needing a calorie-controlled diet.
Hairball control: Designed with increased fiber to help prevent hairball formation.
Indoor Health: Targeted for indoor cats, focusing on weight management and hairball control.
Sensitive Stomach: Crafted to be gentle on the digestive system while offering complete nutrition.

Brand Philosophy and Transparency

Kirkland Cat Food vs Blue Buffalo: Comparison in Detail


  • Philosophy: Offers premium products without the premium price tag.
  • Transparency: Ingredient lists and sourcing are clear, though not as emphasized as with Blue Buffalo.

Blue Buffalo:

  • Philosophy: Prioritizes natural, high-quality ingredients with a family-centric origin story.
  • Transparency: High. Communicates no use of by-product meals and emphasizes natural ingredients. 


If we come to the price range, then Kirkland is generally more affordable per pound, especially when bought in bulk from Costco. However, it is important to consider the quality and ingredients of the product when comparing prices. In this case, you can also ensure they have committed to providing high-quality ingredients at a more budget-friendly price.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo tends to be pricier, reflecting its premium ingredient list and specialized formulas. Emphasizes ingredient transparency and quality, often justifying the higher cost. 

You May Also Like: Weruva vs Tiki Cat Food

FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions

Which brand offers a better ingredient list, Kirkland or Blue Buffalo?

Both Kirkland’s and Blue Buffalo emphasize high-quality ingredients. Blue Buffalo highlights its natural ingredients and avoids using corn, wheat, soy, or chicken (or poultry) by-product meals. As a Costco brand, Kirkland offers quality ingredients at a more budget-friendly price. The “better” ingredient list depends on what specific ingredients or attributes you’re prioritizing for your cat.

Is Blue Buffalo more expensive than Kirkland Cat Food?

The short answer is yes. Blue Buffalo tends to be priced higher per pound compared to Kirkland. However, many cat owners believe the premium ingredient list and specialized formulas of Blue Buffalo justify the higher cost.

Are there any recalls associated with these brands?

Both brands have faced recalls in the past, though for different reasons. It’s always essential to stay updated with the FDA’s recall list and ensure that the specific product batch you’re purchasing is safe for consumption.

Which brand offers more variety for specialized diets?

Blue Buffalo has an extensive range of specialized diets, including limited ingredient diets, weight management formulas, and formulas designed for kittens or seniors. Kirkland also offers variations like kitten, senior, and weight management formulas but may have a narrower range than Blue Buffalo.

Do either of these brands offer grain-free options?

Yes, both brands offer grain-free cat food options. For instance, Blue Buffalo’s Wilderness line is grain-free and high in protein. Kirkland also provides grain-free choices suitable for cats with sensitivities to grains.

How do the two brands compare in terms of taste and palatability for cats?

Taste and palatability largely depend on individual cats and their preferences. Some cats might prefer the taste of one brand over another. Buying smaller packs initially to test which one your cat prefers can be beneficial.

Kirkland Cat Food vs Blue Buffalo Cat Food

Conclusion and Our Final Recommendation:

Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo have their own strengths. Kirkland excels at offering quality at an accessible price point, making it a go-to for many who seek value without compromising nutrition. On the other hand, Blue Buffalo’s commitment to premium, natural ingredients and its wide range of specialized formulas cater to those willing to invest a bit more for specific dietary needs and preferences.

Your choice between Kirkland vs Blue Buffalo should hinge on a combination of factors:

  1. Budget: Kirkland might be your best bet if you’re looking for a blend of quality and affordability, especially in bulk.
  2. Specific Dietary Needs: For cats with particular needs – whether it’s a grain-free diet, sensitivity issues, or breed-specific nutrition – Blue Buffalo’s diverse offerings could be worth the investment.
  3. Ingredient Priorities: Blue Buffalo stands out if a brand’s commitment to natural ingredients and transparent sourcing is of utmost importance.
  4. Brand Philosophy and History: Sometimes, our connection with a brand’s story can influence our decisions. Whether it’s the family-driven tale of Blue Buffalo or the value-centric approach of Kirkland, choose a brand that resonates with you.

About the author

Latest posts

  • Feral Cat Pregnancy: How to Help a Pregnant Stray Cat?

    Feral Cat Pregnancy: How to Help a Pregnant Stray Cat?

    Imagine you’re walking down your neighborhood street when you spot a stray cat with a rounded belly, sauntering past with the grace of nature itself. Your heart twitches a bit as you realize: she’s not just any stray cat—she’s a pregnant stray cat, soon to be a mother, navigating the urban wilderness alone. Helping a…

    Read more

  • Vet Didn’t Give Cone After Neutering Cat: Cone Risks vs Benefits

    Vet Didn’t Give Cone After Neutering Cat: Cone Risks vs Benefits

    Has your cat friend just come back from a neutering procedure, and to your surprise, there’s no cone in sight? Neutering is a significant turning point in your cat’s life, promising a host of health and behavioral benefits. However, the post-op period is crucial and often filled with questions and concerns, especially about the need…

    Read more

  • Is Balsamic Vinegar Safe for Cats or Toxic?

    Is Balsamic Vinegar Safe for Cats or Toxic?

    As we know, balsamic vinegar is a dark, concentrated, and intensely flavored vinegar originating from Italy. It’s made from grape must, which is the juice of freshly crushed grapes, including the skins, seeds, and stems. As an expert in feline nutrition and pet care, the question of whether is balsamic vinegar safe for cats is…

    Read more